Under Florida law, a residential condo's optional termination plan stops if 5 percent or more of the total voting interests reject it. At Biscayne 21, the 192-unit bayfront building at 2121 North Bayshore Drive, the owners who refused to sell held eight units. Counted by units, that's about 4.2 percent of the building, short of the 5 percent mark. They won anyway. The developer's affiliate later paid them roughly $50 million, according to a source cited by The Real Deal.
Their protection came from a sentence in Biscayne 21's own condo declaration.
The Arithmetic That Should Have Ended It
Florida Statutes §718.117(3) governs optional termination. It lets a residential association send a termination plan to the state once at least 80 percent of total voting interests approve it, and it bars the plan if 5 percent or more reject it. The statute counts voting interests. The table below counts units, which matches the statute only if each unit carries one vote.
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Units in the building | 192 |
| Statutory approval floor for optional termination | 80% of total voting interests |
| Rejection that blocks an optional termination plan | 5% or more of total voting interests |
| 5% of 192 units | 9.6 units |
| Units held by the holdout owners | 8 |
| Holdout share of units | about 4.2% |
Counted by units, eight was not enough to block the plan under the statute. Ten owners held those eight units, according to Biscayne Times, and their dispute ran more than three years.
What the Declaration Said
Biscayne 21's original declaration required every owner, 100 percent, to approve termination. As The Real Deal recounted, after Two Roads Development bought most of the units in 2022, the developer-controlled association amended that threshold down to 80 percent. The amendment was the hinge of the whole deal.
The Third District Court of Appeal ruled that the amendment changed the owners' voting rights. It reversed a lower court that had denied the holdouts a temporary injunction. In July 2025 the court denied rehearing and held that a simple majority vote could not amend away the declaration's unanimity requirement. The Florida Supreme Court declined to hear the case in October 2025, which left the developer no further appeal.
The ruling turned on this building's own document. The original 100 percent clause gave each unit owner an effective veto, and a later majority vote could not remove it. A different declaration with a different threshold would have produced a different case.
What the Clause Was Worth
The value of that veto shows up as a set of prices for the same building.
- About $785,000 per unit. That's the 2022 bulk purchase, in which Two Roads paid about $150 million for most of the building, as reported by The Real Deal at the time.
- Nearly $1.3 million. That's what Two Roads offered one holdout owner in early 2021 for a renovated three-bedroom unit with a bay view. He had asked for about a third more.
- Roughly $6.3 million per owner grouping. That's the August 2026 settlement, based on The Real Deal's reported total of about $50 million.
The sellers' side said collective bargaining in 2022 brought more than three times what owners would likely have gotten selling one at a time. The holdouts earned many times more than the bulk sellers, mostly because of time and leverage. Speaking with The Real Deal, the owner who had asked for a third more put a figure on what it would have cost to avoid the fight.
"[Two Roads] could have avoided everything that happened by paying me and my neighbor a combined total of $600,000 to $700,000 above the bulk sale price."
The developer was under pressure too. In January 2026, a Miami-Dade judge ordered the developer's affiliate, TRD Biscayne, to restore the building and its utilities at its own expense, reinstate the association and deeds, and stop pursuing zoning approvals or demolition permits. Biscayne Times put the possible repair bill at up to $65 million. Weighed against that bill, a settlement around $50 million was the cheaper way out, and a declaration clause had driven both sides to that number.
From Bulk Purchase to Settlement
The case took four years from the 2022 purchase to the 2026 settlement. Here is the sequence.
- May 2022. Two Roads buys most of the units for about $150 million and plans up to three towers with as many as 750 units.
- September 2022. Sales launch for a 55-story, 185-unit Edition Residences tower, with prices starting at $1.7 million. A termination plan is filed that year.
- May 2023. The holdout owners sue over the amended termination threshold.
- March 2024 through July 2025. The Third District Court of Appeal rules for the holdouts and later denies rehearing.
- October 2025. The Florida Supreme Court declines review.
- January 2026. The court orders the building restored at the developer's expense.
- August 31, 2026. The settlement is reached and funded. The Real Deal reported that day that a court still had to sign off on it.
In early October, managing partner Taylor Collins told Biscayne Times that the settlement was "fully funded and finalized." He said demolition would start in the coming weeks to make way for the Arquitectonica-designed Edition Residences, Miami Edgewater. Commercial Observer reported in early September that the project was 40 percent presold. For transparency, Ruben is affiliated with Douglas Elliman, and Douglas Elliman was hired in 2022 to launch sales of the Edition tower.
The Push to Change Termination Rules
As of the 2026 Florida Statutes, the 80 percent approval floor and 5 percent rejection bar for optional termination still stand. The Florida Senate's 2026 bill search shows no bill citing §718.117. The session's broad community-association package, HB 657, did not reach condo termination, and it died in Senate Rules on March 13, 2026.
Both sides in the Biscayne 21 case have called on the Legislature to act. Collins told The Real Deal that Florida needs "a clear, fair and predictable process for terminating condominium associations, particularly as so many buildings reach or exceed their useful life." A May 2026 analysis from the law firm Bilzin Sumberg describes an effort being prepared for the 2027 session to rewrite §718.117(2), the subsection on termination for economic waste or impossibility. According to that analysis, the proposal would likely:
- Replace the current variable threshold, which is tied to the declaration's own amendment percentage, with a fixed supermajority such as 80 percent
- Add a cost-to-value test comparing necessary repair costs with the aggregate value of the units
- Apply to existing associations regardless of when their declarations were recorded, which Bilzin expects to be the most contested piece
No 2027 bill citing §718.117 had shown up in the Senate's 2027 search when it was last checked.
The pressure is spreading beyond one building. In May 2026, The Real Deal reported that 80 percent of owners at the 134-unit St. Louis condominium on Brickell Key had agreed to negotiate a buyout with Terra Group and Related Group, at an estimated price near $1.5 million per unit. Developers chase these deals because there is very little undeveloped land left on the water.
Quick Answers
Is Biscayne 21 already demolished? As of early October 2026, Two Roads said demolition would begin in the coming weeks. When the settlement was announced on August 31, The Real Deal reported that a court still had to sign off on it.
Did Florida change termination rules in 2026? No bill citing §718.117 was filed in the 2026 session, and HB 657 died in committee. A 2027 proposal has been described by Bilzin Sumberg but had not been filed when last checked.
If you own in an older Edgewater building or are weighing one, Ruben Chamorro can help you pull the recorded declaration and buyout history for each building on your shortlist. Work With Ruben & Get Access To The Most Exclusive Listings.